Minnesota · Uncategorized

Minneapolis vs Saint Paul: a fresh look after 8 years

Minneapolis established in 1867 and St. Paul established a bit earlier in 1854, often referred to as the Twin Cities, share many similarities but also have distinct differences that might sway someone’s preference for living in one city over the other. The downtowns are only 7 miles apart but there are a lot of differences between the two cities and I think a lot of it comes down to “vibe”. Like, maybe “chill” vs “not chill”.

Differences Between Minneapolis and St. Paul (Saint Paul was formerly known as PIGS EYE! Good decision to change that name!):

  1. Cityscape and Vibe: Minneapolis tends to have a more modern and cosmopolitan feel with a vibrant downtown area, skyscrapers, and a bustling arts and nightlife scene. St. Paul, as the state capital, has a more historic charm with beautiful architecture, cozy neighborhoods, and a quieter atmosphere.
  2. Cultural Offerings: Minneapolis is known for its thriving arts scene, hosting major theaters, galleries, and music venues like the Guthrie Theater and First Avenue. St. Paul, on the other hand, embraces its history and heritage with iconic landmarks such as the Cathedral of Saint Paul and the Minnesota History Center.
  3. Dining and Cuisine: Both cities offer diverse culinary experiences, but Minneapolis is often recognized for its trendy restaurants, food trucks, and fusion cuisine, catering to a more adventurous palate. St. Paul leans towards classic diners, family-owned eateries, and establishments that celebrate traditional comfort foods.
  4. Outdoor Recreation: Minneapolis is renowned for its chain of lakes, extensive parks, and bike-friendly trails, providing ample opportunities for outdoor activities like jogging, biking, and water sports. St. Paul boasts a scenic riverfront and more spacious parks, offering a quieter and more serene outdoor experience.
  5. Community and Lifestyle: Minneapolis is known for its diverse and cosmopolitan population, attracting people from various backgrounds and fostering a bustling city life. St. Paul, with its strong sense of community and neighborhood pride, tends to offer a cozier and more tight-knit atmosphere.
  6. Festivals: Saint Paul: Winter CarnivalSt. Patrick’s Day ParadeIrish FairTwin Cities Jazz FestHmong New Year Minneapolis: Twin Cities Pride, Loppet Ski Festival, Aquatennial, Basilica Block Party, U.S. Pond Hockey Championships
  7. LAKES: Saint Paul – 7 measly lakes. Minneapolis: coming in at 13 glorious and large lakes, earning one of it’s nicknames “The City of Lakes”.
  8. Population: St. Paul = 303,176 and Minneapolis = 425,096.
  9. Fortune 500 HQs: St. Paul has 4 and Minneapolis is the big poppa coming in at 6. The state of Minnesota is home to 15 Fortune 500 companies.
  10. Breweries: People like their beer in St. Paul – they have 17 breweries, but Minneapolis likes it more apparently, there are 32 breweries in Minneapolis. Try them all! But not on the same day.
  11. Colleges: The twin Cities is FULL of well-educated smarties, but more of them are larnin’ over in STP – there are 9 colleges located in the city limits of St. Paul while there are “only” 7 colleges in Minneapolis. Although, again, Minneapolis is home to the big dog, er, GOPHER, in the form of the University of Minnesota. The colleges on the St. Paul side of the river tend to be smaller, private colleges like St. Thomas, McCalester College and St. Catherines.

Some other differences of note:

  1. Housing Affordability and Age of Homes: St. Paul tends to have slightly more affordable housing compared to Minneapolis, with home prices typically being lower. Additionally, homes in St. Paul often lean towards older and more historic structures, offering a different architectural feel compared to the relatively newer housing options in Minneapolis
  2. Infrastructure and Winter Accessibility: Both cities boast skyway systems in their downtown areas, allowing residents and visitors to navigate the urban core without stepping outside, especially during harsh winter months. This feature provides convenience and shelter from extreme weather conditions, a significant advantage for those living and working in the downtown areas. The light rail does travel down University Avenue between both cities.
  3. Winter Maintenance: While the skyway system helps in navigating the winter, one common complaint (from ME) about St. Paul, is its snow plowing efforts. Prepare for some bumpy driving. Some residents have experienced “challenges” with the city’s snow removal services, resulting in difficulties commuting or driving during heavy snowfalls compared to Minneapolis, which might prioritize snow clearance more efficiently. But after living in Chicago for a long time where they take snow removal VERY seriously, I’m not giving either city a gold star.

Choosing Between Minneapolis and St. Paul with Additional Insights:

  • Choose Minneapolis If: You prefer a vibrant urban lifestyle with a bustling arts scene, trendy dining options, and a more modern cityscape. Minneapolis might be the ideal choice for those seeking a diverse, fast-paced city life with plenty of entertainment options and a youthful vibe.
  • Choose St. Paul If: You appreciate historic charm, a quieter pace of life, and a stronger sense of community. St. Paul might appeal to those who enjoy a more intimate city feel, where neighborhoods are tight-knit, cultural heritage is cherished, and a slower-paced lifestyle is embraced.
  • Consider St. Paul If: You’re looking for more affordable housing options with a touch of historical charm. St. Paul might appeal to those who prefer older homes and a more budget-friendly housing market. The skyway system can also be a significant advantage during cold winters if you work or spend considerable time downtown.
  • Consider Minneapolis If: You’re interested in newer housing options and a more efficient approach to winter snow removal. Minneapolis may be a better fit for individuals seeking a more modern living environment and possibly smoother winter travel experiences.
  • Winter Considerations: It’s important to note that while both cities offer skyway systems for winter convenience, St. Paul’s potential challenges with snow removal could impact commuting and daily activities during harsh winter conditions.

Ultimately, the choice between Minneapolis and St. Paul often comes down to personal preferences in terms of lifestyle, community, entertainment, and the overall atmosphere one seeks in a city to call home. Both cities offer unique experiences and opportunities, making the Twin Cities region a dynamic and diverse place to live.

Neighborhood Tours

Highland Park Neighborhood St. Paul

I suffer from nostalgia and I’m a sucker for charming old homes and neighborhoods that remind me of movie sets. And that’s why I feel squishy inside when I spend time in Highland Park in St. Paul.  It’s a condition, don’t mock me!  

Types of homes

The Highland Park neighborhood of St Paul is right next to the MacGroveland neighborhood and shares so many of the same characteristics.  The homes are here older and filled with all of that original charm. St. Paul was settled before Minneapolis and the housing stock there reflects it in many areas.

Many of the homes were built in the early 1900’s and often have original hard wood floors, beautiful wide wood moldings, built-ins, plaster walls, detached garages and other features of homes built at that time. Another feature that I love on old homes that you’ll often see here are porches where you can sit and enjoy the gorgeous weather that we have here spring through fall. I think porches and sidewalks encourage a sense of community and give opportunities to see and talk to neighbors. 

As you enter the neighborhood from the west on Ford Parkway you’ll notice a large construction site which is a planned community / new construction development, so if you want the city lifestyle and access but AREN’T interested in old homes, this can be a great option for you. It’s called Highland Bridge and its a couple of different developments including row homes and a senior living development, community park, shops and restaurants. This won’t be where you find a bargain –  row homes are at the upper end of the pricing for this part of St. Paul at $1.5M+, there are also custom single family homes being built with lot prices starting at around $500K.

Amenities

One of the things I like about city living is the access to sidewalks and bike lanes as well as the ability to get to restaurants parks and shops relatively easily, on foot, on bike, or in a vehicle. Highland Park is home to all of these things, it has a robust commercial area so you won’t need to go far to grab a bite or do some shopping and recreation is convenient as well, it has a golf course, and  easy access to the massive park system along the Mississippi River with all of the bike trails that run throughout (72 miles along the Mississippi rover alone!) and connect to so many local and regional trails in the Minneapolis St Paul region. 


Another stand out to me was the local library branch and the Highland Park Rec Center which offers Highland Park Community Center offers educational programs, after school activities, open gymtot-times, family events, fitness center memberships, youth and adult athleticsS’more Fun childcare, Highland Park Community Center Theatre, field rentalsrental space for parties, meetings, and events, and so much more.

Home prices

The average home price in Highland Park for the typical house is a little more than $441K, its charming neighbor, MacGroveland is just a little bit more from an average home price perspective. 

Access

This neighborhood also has easy access to both Minneapolis and St. Paul for work – as well as the freeways that lead to the South, SW and SE suburbs, or anywhere that you want to go within the metro area. Typically if you work on one side of the river you try to live on that side for easy commuting, but I think Highland Park benefits from a great central location from a commuting perspective.  Light rail is also within 1 mile of the neighborhood and there is a bus system in St. Paul.

It seems like one of the big benefits of the suburbs would be easy access to stores like Target, and Highland Park actually has an adorable little Target in their main commercial area off of Ford Parkway & Cleveland. 

Shopping

Groceries are within easy reach at the Target, Lunds and Byerlys or a short drive to Kowalskis. 

Schools

Children living in this area will attend St. Paul public schools Horace Mann Elementary, Highland Park Middle School, and Highland Park Senior High.

Whether you like historic homes with that old fashioned charm or you’re looking for new construction urban townhomes, this neighborhood has both, along with all the things that people choose city living for.